Quantum technology, once the stuff of science fiction, is rapidly becoming a cornerstone of future innovation. Nations around the globe are racing to harness the power of quantum mechanics, aiming to revolutionize industries from computing to communication, and from healthcare to energy. This “World Quantum Race” isn’t just about achieving scientific breakthroughs; it’s about establishing dominance in a field that promises to redefine our technological landscape. With the promise of revolutionizing computing, communication, and sensing, the race to quantum supremacy has become a geopolitical priority. The stakes are high, with projections estimating the quantum computing market could reach $1.7 billion by 2026, and a Boston Consulting Group report suggesting it could near $60 billion by 2035 and $295 billion by 2050.
Governments in Canada, China, Europe, and North America are devoting multi-billion-dollar programs to quantum technologies, and commercial investment is flowing as well. Leading venture and private equity funds as well as major corporations compete for rapid investments of considerable size. They are also experimenting with different models involving Industry and academia to give thrust to this now strategic field. Central to this race are the quantum technology hubs, coordination offices, and international forums that are driving global collaboration and competition.
Quantum Technology Hubs: The New Centers of Excellence
The quantum race is not just about who can build the most powerful quantum computer first; it’s about establishing global centers of excellence that can attract talent, foster innovation, and drive start-up growth. The global race for quantum computing dominance is being shaped by the strategic development of Quantum Centres of Excellence, which are emerging as vital hubs for innovation. These centers are typically located near leading universities and institutions with deep expertise in quantum technologies.
Quantum technology hubs are geographic regions with a high concentration of quantum research, development, and commercialization activities. These hubs typically house universities, research institutions, startups, and established companies working on various aspects of quantum technology, from hardware to software and applications.
Quantum technology hubs have sprung up across the world, each serving as a nexus for research, development, and commercialization of quantum technologies. These hubs are often based in leading universities and research institutions, where they bring together physicists, engineers, and computer scientists to tackle some of the most complex problems in quantum mechanics.
Key characteristics of successful quantum hubs:
However, the true global centers of gravity in quantum computing will be determined by how effectively these locations can cultivate their ecosystems. Success will depend on their ability to attract top-tier talent, foster startup growth, and secure substantial investment, ensuring a sustainable and innovative environment that propels quantum advancements.
- Talent Pool: A strong concentration of quantum physicists, engineers, and computer scientists.
- Research Infrastructure: Advanced laboratories and equipment for experimentation and development.
- Industry Collaboration: Close ties between academia and industry to accelerate technology transfer.
- Government Support: Financial incentives, regulatory frameworks, and policy support for quantum initiatives.
- Vibrant Ecosystem: A thriving startup culture and a supportive environment for entrepreneurs.
The United States: Leading the Charge
In August 2020, the U.S. Department of Energy announced a significant investment of $625 million over the next five years to support the development of five new quantum information research hubs. This funding, part of the broader $1.2 billion allocated through the National Quantum Initiative Act of 2018, aims to bolster the United States’ position in quantum technology and maintain its competitive edge against nations like China. The National Quantum Initiative Act, enacted in September 2018, commits $1.275 billion to advance research and training in quantum computing, establishing centers of excellence designed to cultivate a new generation of quantum engineers. Experts like Harvard’s Prineha Narang emphasize that expanding basic research and training will be crucial for developing quantum technologies and finding their commercial applications.
In the U.S., recent legislation is set to authorize the Department of Energy (DOE) and the National Science Foundation (NSF) to establish new research centers at universities, federal laboratories, and nonprofit research institutes. These hubs are designed to bridge the gap between fundamental research and commercial applications by uniting physicists, engineers, and computer scientists. As physicist David Awschalom of the University of Chicago notes, the collaborative environment will provide academics with access to specialized expertise and costly research tools, essential for advancing quantum technologies. Similarly, the UK is bolstering its quantum strategy by investing £120 million in a national network of quantum technology hubs. Led by prominent universities, these hubs focus on transitioning from scientific discovery to technological innovation, with investments in incubator spaces and facilities to support the development of next-generation quantum devices.
In the United States, recent legislation has paved the way for the creation of new quantum research centers at universities, federal laboratories, and nonprofit research institutes. These hubs are designed to build alliances between physicists, engineers, and computer scientists, creating a collaborative environment that accelerates quantum technology development. The focus areas include ultraprecise quantum sensors, hack-proof quantum communication, and quantum computing.
For instance, the United States has established several key quantum hubs, including the Chicago Quantum Exchange, the Quantum Information Science and Technology Center at MIT, and the Berkeley Quantum Information and Computation Center. These hubs not only conduct cutting-edge research but also collaborate with private sector companies to translate quantum research into practical applications.
The U.S. quantum landscape features several key hubs, including Silicon Valley, the North Carolina State Quantum Hub, the Berkeley Quantum, the Chicago Quantum Exchange, the Quantum Technology Centre at the University of Maryland, the Harvard Quantum Initiative, and the Pittsburgh Quantum Initiative. Notably, the Chicago region has been designated as a U.S. Tech Hub for quantum technologies, with the Chicago Quantum Exchange spearheading initiatives in this area. The city has received substantial funding to establish itself as a national quantum leader, supported by collaborations among top research institutions like the University of Chicago, Argonne National Laboratory, and Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory. This initiative includes the development of long-distance quantum communication links and a strong focus on workforce development, ensuring the U.S. remains at the forefront of quantum innovation.
Canada: Building a Quantum Ecosystem
United Kingdom: A National Strategy for Quantum Technologies
The United Kingdom has made significant strides in quantum research and development, establishing itself as a key player on the global stage. The UK’s commitment began in earnest with the launch of its first five-year quantum initiative in 2015, which proved successful enough to warrant a second phase announced at the end of 2019. Central to this effort is the UK’s National Strategy for Quantum Technologies, which aims to guide quantum innovation and investment over the next two decades. This strategy envisions creating a cohesive community of government, industry, and academia that will secure a world-leading position for the UK in the burgeoning multi-billion-pound quantum technology markets. The focus is on leveraging quantum advancements to enhance the value of the UK’s key industries while fostering a profitable and sustainable quantum sector rooted in the UK.
The UK’s quantum program initially received £270 million in 2014, with £120 million allocated to establish four National Quantum Technology Hubs at leading universities in Oxford, Birmingham, York, and Glasgow. Despite additional funding, such as the £80 million announced in 2018, the UK’s investment is still considerably less than its global counterparts, with Bloomberg noting that it is 12 times less than the US’s annual quantum funding and significantly less than China’s massive $10 billion commitment. Nonetheless, the UK has made notable progress, with over 30 universities participating in quantum research, alongside industry and government partners. The focus areas include quantum imaging, ultra-precise sensors, secure communications, and quantum computing. Oxford has particularly emerged as the UK’s central quantum computing hub, highlighted by a £93 million investment in the National Quantum Computing Centre. Additionally, quantum hubs have been developed in London, Cambridge, Bristol, and across Scottish universities, underscoring the UK’s robust and geographically diverse approach to quantum technology development.
Europe
Europe has maintained a significant presence in the field of quantum research, a legacy rooted in the pioneering work of Einstein, Schrödinger, and other scientific luminaries. The continent continues to lead in academic quantum output and has made substantial investments to bolster its position in this critical area. In 2018, the European Commission launched the European Quantum Flagship, a €1 billion initiative spread over ten years. The flagship’s primary goal is to solidify and expand Europe’s scientific leadership in quantum technologies while fostering the development of a robust European quantum industry. This initiative, endorsed by over 3,500 representatives from academia and industry, reflects Europe’s commitment to positioning quantum technologies as a cornerstone of future technological advancements.
France
France has emerged as a key player in quantum technologies, investing €60 million annually to advance its research and development. The French government has laid out an ambitious national strategy for quantum technologies, estimating that €1.4 billion will be needed over the next five years to fully realize its goals. Recognizing the limitations of public funding, the French government has called for significant private sector involvement to support this initiative. The 2020 plan outlines strategic recommendations, including the deployment of cutting-edge quantum computing infrastructure, launching a comprehensive technological development program, fostering innovation through tailored economic security measures, and establishing effective governance. These efforts aim to position France as a global leader in quantum technologies, driving both scientific discovery and industrial application.
Germany
Germany has been proactive in its approach to quantum technologies, launching a Framework Programme in 2018 to bring these innovations to market. The German Federal Government allocated €650 million to support this initiative, with a focus on building on the country’s strong foundation in quantum physics research. The program’s goals include preparing Germany for new economic opportunities and markets, securing a leading role in the industrial application of quantum technologies, and working with international partners to ensure security and autonomy in this critical field. In July 2020, Germany further reinforced its commitment with a €2 billion quantum initiative, complementing the European Union’s broader €1 billion investment plan through 2028. This comprehensive approach underscores Germany’s dedication to becoming a global leader in quantum technology.
The Netherlands
The Netherlands has positioned itself as a formidable player in the global quantum landscape, driven by the publication of its National Agenda on Quantum Technologies in 2019. This agenda focuses on four key areas: breakthroughs in research and innovation, ecosystem development and market creation, education and skill development, and societal dialogue on quantum technology. The Dutch government aims to establish the Netherlands as a leading international hub for quantum technologies, capitalizing on its strong research capabilities in quantum internet, quantum algorithms, and post-quantum cryptography. A significant investment of €135 million from six parties has been directed towards QuTech, the quantum technology institute of TU Delft and TNO, bringing the total investment to approximately $150 million. This commitment underscores the Netherlands’ ambition to be at the forefront of quantum innovation.
Australia
Australia has made a strong commitment to advancing quantum technologies with a federal investment of AU$130 million, complemented by state-level funding. In 2017, Australia established two key Centres of Excellence: FLEET (Future Low-Energy Electronics Technologies) at Monash University and Exciton Science at the University of Melbourne. The Centre of Excellence for Quantum Computation and Communication Technology (CQC2T) gained significant recognition when its Director, Professor Michelle Simmons, was named Australian of the Year in 2018. Additionally, the Australian Research Council Centre of Excellence for Engineered Quantum Systems (EQUS) was created to drive transformative quantum research. The Sydney Quantum Academy (SQA), launched in December 2020 with support from the New South Wales government, aims to foster collaboration among Macquarie University, UNSW Sydney, the University of Sydney, and the University of Technology Sydney. The SQA, funded by a $26 million quantum computing fund, focuses on skills development and promoting partnerships between academia, industry, and government.
In Australia, the New South Wales (NSW) government has taken significant steps to advance quantum technologies by backing the Sydney Quantum Academy (SQA). This initiative brings together researchers from four major universities—University of Sydney, University of New South Wales, Macquarie University, and University of Technology Sydney—to collaborate on quantum research and link their findings to industry applications. The NSW government has committed $15.4 million in funding, with an additional $20 million contributed by the participating universities and industry partners. The academy’s objectives are to encourage cross-institutional collaboration, connect students with industry through internships and research opportunities, support emerging quantum technology startups, and establish Sydney as a global leader in quantum research and development.
University of Technology Sydney (UTS) Centre for Quantum Software and Information (CQSI)
Similarly, the University of Technology Sydney (UTS) has inaugurated the Centre for Quantum Software and Information (CQSI), dedicated to advancing software and information processing technologies crucial for quantum applications. UTS Deputy Vice-Chancellor of Research, Glenn Wightwick, highlighted that CQSI will play a pivotal role in developing the infrastructure necessary to support quantum-scale applications. In the U.S., the Center for Quantum Science and Engineering (CQSE) at Stevens Institute of Technology is making strides in quantum engineering by integrating photonic technologies, networking, remote sensing, machine learning, big data processing, and quantum computing into its research and educational efforts.
The Centre for Quantum Software and Information (CQSI) at the University of Technology Sydney (UTS) focuses on five core research areas: quantum algorithms and complexity, artificial intelligence applications, quantum programming and verification, intermediate quantum computing and architectures, and quantum information theory and security.
Quantum Algorithms and Complexity: CQSI explores fundamental questions about leveraging quantum mechanics for real-world problem-solving, enriching quantum algorithm frameworks, and understanding the limitations of quantum computing. The centre investigates existing methodologies like quantum Fourier transforms and amplitude amplification, while also developing new techniques to address challenges in AI, machine learning, big data, and optimization. The aim is to uncover broader applications of quantum algorithms and their theoretical boundaries.
AI Applications of Quantum Computing: CQSI examines the intersection of quantum computing and artificial intelligence, focusing on spatial and temporal reasoning, quantum constraint solving, quantum machine learning, and quantum property testing. The research aims to develop quantum algorithms for complex constraints and optimization problems and to enhance AI capabilities with quantum computing.
Intermediate Quantum Computing and Architectures: The centre is dedicated to exploring quantum supremacy and developing practical quantum computing architectures. Research includes identifying benchmarks for demonstrating quantum supremacy, designing architectures to achieve these benchmarks, and collaborating with experimental teams to realize them.
Quantum Programming and Verification: This research area addresses the unique challenges of programming quantum computers and developing verification methods. The centre investigates new programming models to exploit quantum features like superposition and entanglement, and aims to create formal methods and tools for verifying quantum programs and cryptographic protocols.
Quantum Information Theory and Security: CQSI focuses on advancing quantum information and communication technologies, including quantum cryptography. The centre aims to develop theories and technologies for quantum-enhanced networks that offer superior security and privacy, addressing emerging threats in communications.
The Rise of Quantum Hubs in Asia
Asia is not far behind, with China making significant strides through its National Laboratory for Quantum Information Sciences and Japan’s Quantum ICT Forum. These hubs are supported by robust government funding and have already achieved remarkable milestones, such as China’s quantum satellite, Micius, which has set the stage for a new era of secure quantum communication.
China: A Quantum Powerhouse
China stands at the forefront of global quantum information science, having made substantial investments in the field since the late 1990s. It is estimated that the Chinese government has allocated around $10 billion towards quantum technologies, although this figure remains unverified officially. This early and aggressive investment strategy has enabled China to emerge as a global leader in quantum research, with significant advancements and infrastructure developments in place. Beijing University and the University of Electronic Science and Technology in Chengdu have been particularly notable for their contributions, with the highest number of quantum computing patents being filed at these institutions.
In addition to its academic and research achievements, China has made remarkable strides in quantum communications. The country has launched the world’s first quantum communication landline connecting Beijing and Shanghai and facilitated the first quantum-encrypted Skype call, enabled by the groundbreaking Micius satellite. These milestones reflect China’s ambition to dominate the quantum technology arena through state-led initiatives and substantial financial commitments, potentially reaching tens of billions of dollars in future investments. The 13th five-year plan, introduced in 2016, outlines a “megaproject” aimed at achieving major breakthroughs in quantum computing and communications by 2030. This includes the expansion of national quantum communication infrastructure and the development of quantum computer prototypes and practical simulators.
China’s interest in quantum technology extends to its military applications, with the People’s Liberation Army (PLA) exploring innovations in quantum radar and sensing. These technologies are envisioned to counteract the U.S. military’s stealth capabilities and enhance China’s defense mechanisms. The PLA Navy, for instance, is working on a quantum compass for submarines to navigate independently of satellite systems, which could be compromised in conflict scenarios. Furthermore, quantum cryptography promises to secure military communications against potential threats, underscoring China’s strategic focus on leveraging quantum advancements for national security and technological superiority.
A study of China’s quantum strategy published in September 2018 by the Center for a New American Security (CNAS), a US think tank, noted that the Chinese People’s Liberation Army (PLA) is recruiting quantum specialists, and that big defense companies like China Shipbuilding Industry Corporation (CSIC) are setting up joint quantum labs at universities. Working out exactly which projects have a military element to them is hard, though. “There’s a degree of opacity and ambiguity here, and some of that may be deliberate,” says Elsa Kania, a coauthor of the CNAS study. China has also managed to cultivate close working relationships between government research institutes, universities, and companies like CSIC and CETC.
Emerging Quantum Hubs: South Korea, India, Japan, Israel, and Russia
India, Israel, and Russia are also emerging as key players in the global quantum race. India has launched a National Mission on Quantum Technologies and Applications with a budget of approximately $1 billion over five years. Israel’s QUEST center and Russia’s Quantum Center are driving research and development in quantum computing, quantum communication, and quantum sensing.
South Korea
South Korea is making significant strides in quantum technology with strategic investments aimed at advancing core technologies. The government plans to allocate KRW 44.5 billion ($39.7 million) over the next five years to enhance quantum computing capabilities and expand the research base. This funding will support the development of cutting-edge quantum technologies and the establishment of a robust research infrastructure. Additionally, KRW 13.4 billion ($11.9 million) will be invested in next-generation ICT technologies, including ultra-high-performance computing, data convergence, system software, and human-computer interaction. By 2023, the government aims to demonstrate a practical five-qubit quantum computer system with over 90 percent reliability, marking a significant milestone in the nation’s quantum technology journey.
Japan
Japan is intensifying its efforts to advance quantum technology through a comprehensive national strategy that fosters collaboration among government, industry, and academia. The government’s plan includes a detailed roadmap spanning about 20 years, targeting key areas such as quantum computers and quantum cryptography. With an investment of around ¥30 billion ($280 million), Japan’s key funding agencies include the Japan Science and Technology Agency, the National Institute of Information and Communications Technology, and the Japan Society for the Promotion of Science. The Q-LEAP initiative, launched in 2018, focuses on quantum simulation, computation, sensing, and ultrashort pulse lasers. Additionally, the Moonshot Project aims to invest ¥15-20 billion to achieve a fault-tolerant universal quantum computer by 2050, reflecting Japan’s commitment to maintaining a leading position in global quantum technology development.
Japan has established the Quantum ICT Forum, a collaborative effort involving 19 businesses and 16 research institutes. This forum, initiated by major electronics companies, universities, and state-owned research organizations, aims to accelerate the development of quantum technology. The forum will facilitate information sharing and strategy formulation to set global standards for quantum technology. Professor Akihisa Tomita of Hokkaido University, the forum’s head, emphasizes the importance of collaboration among government, industry, and academia to enhance Japan’s competitive edge in the rapidly evolving quantum technology sector
India
India is advancing its quantum technology capabilities through significant government investment and research initiatives. The Indian Institute of Science (IISc) leads the Initiative on Quantum Technology, focusing on areas such as superconducting qubit devices, single photon sources for quantum communications, and quantum sensors. This year, the Indian government introduced the National Mission on Quantum Technologies and Applications (NM-QTA) with a budget of INR 8000 crores (approximately $1 billion) over five years. Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman emphasized that this initiative aims to foster commercial applications stemming from theoretical advancements in quantum technology, positioning India as a key player in the global quantum research landscape.
Israel
Israel is advancing quantum technology through the QUEST (QUantum Entanglement in Science and Technology) center, which supports both fundamental and applied quantum research. The Israeli government has allocated 1.2 billion shekels ($350 million) over six years for a comprehensive quantum technology program. This funding, provided by the Council of Higher Education, the Defense Ministry’s Research, Arms Development and Technological Infrastructure Administration, and various academic institutions, will drive innovation and research in the field. Additionally, Google’s R&D center in Tel Aviv is making notable progress in quantum computing, with recent developments indicating the potential of quantum chips to process data at unprecedented speeds, showcasing Israel’s burgeoning role in the global quantum technology arena.
Singapore
The Centre for Quantum Technologies (CQT) in Singapore exemplifies a leading national Research Centre of Excellence (RCE), uniting physicists, computer scientists, and engineers to advance the field of quantum technologies. Established in December 2007 with backing from Singapore’s National Research Foundation and Ministry of Education, CQT operates under the National University of Singapore (NUS) and extends its reach to Nanyang Technological University (NTU) and Singapore University of Technology and Design (SUTD). The centre focuses on fundamental research in quantum physics and translates these discoveries into practical applications across computing, communications, and sensing domains.
Since its inception, the Centre has published around 2,000 scientific papers, secured over S$40 million in grants, and trained more than 60 PhD students in quantum technologies. To further its mission, CQT is investing S$25 million over five years into a new Quantum Engineering Programme, with additional contributions from various grants and the Quantum Engineering Programme (QEP1), totaling approximately S$150 million in quantum research expenditures over the past five years.
Coordination Offices: The Heart of Quantum Strategy
While quantum hubs are essential for driving innovation, effective coordination and collaboration are equally important. Governments, industry, and academia must work together to create a cohesive ecosystem.
As the quantum race intensifies, the need for coordination at the national and international levels has become increasingly apparent. Coordination offices play a crucial role in aligning research efforts, setting standards, and ensuring that resources are effectively allocated. In the U.S., the National Quantum Coordination Office (NQCO) acts as the nerve center for the country’s quantum strategy, coordinating initiatives across federal agencies, fostering public-private partnerships, and aligning efforts with international allies.
Similarly, the European Union has established the Quantum Coordination and Support Action (QCSA) to oversee the implementation of the Quantum Flagship program, ensuring that Europe’s quantum ambitions are met in a coordinated and cohesive manner. These coordination offices are essential in navigating the complex landscape of quantum research and in maximizing the impact of investments in this field.
Key elements of successful coordination:
- Standardization: Developing common standards and protocols for quantum technologies to ensure compatibility and interoperability.
- Data Sharing: Facilitating the exchange of research data and insights to accelerate progress.
- Talent Development: Investing in education and training programs to build a skilled quantum workforce.
- Intellectual Property Protection: Establishing robust intellectual property rights to encourage innovation.
- International Cooperation: Collaborating with other countries to share knowledge and resources.
International Forums: A Global Collaborative Effort
The World Quantum Race is not just a competition; it’s also a collaborative effort that requires global coordination. International forums provide the platforms necessary for countries to share knowledge, establish standards, and cooperate on large-scale quantum projects. The World Economic Forum’s Global Future Council on Quantum Computing, for example, brings together leading experts from academia, industry, and government to discuss the future of quantum technology and its global implications.
Other significant forums include the Quantum Internet Alliance, which aims to build a global quantum internet, and the Quantum Industry Consortium, which fosters collaboration between quantum startups and established tech giants. These forums are instrumental in breaking down the silos that often exist between different countries and sectors, facilitating the exchange of ideas and ensuring that the benefits of quantum technology are shared globally.
Conclusion: The Future of the Quantum Race
The world quantum race is more than just a competition to build the most advanced quantum computers. It’s about establishing global hubs and centers of excellence that can drive innovation, attract talent, and create a sustainable quantum ecosystem. The establishment of quantum technology hubs, coordination offices, and international forums has set the stage for a new era of technological innovation. These institutions are not just competing to be the first to achieve quantum supremacy; they are also working together to build a global quantum ecosystem that will shape the future of technology for decades to come.
As countries continue to pour resources into quantum research, the race is far from over. The challenges of developing scalable quantum computers, secure quantum communication networks, and quantum sensors are immense, and the solutions will likely require unprecedented levels of international collaboration.
As countries continue to invest in quantum technologies, the landscape of quantum research and development will continue to evolve, with new players emerging and existing hubs solidifying their positions as leaders in this transformative field. The race is on, and the stakes have never been higher.
In the end, the World Quantum Race is about more than just winning. It’s about creating a new technological paradigm that has the potential to solve some of the world’s most pressing problems. And while the race may never truly have a finish line, the journey promises to be one of the most exciting and impactful endeavors of the 21st century.
References and Resources also include:
https://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/china/2018-09-26/chinas-quantum-future
https://www.technologyreview.com/s/612421/us-china-quantum-arms-race/
https://www3.nhk.or.jp/nhkworld/en/news/20191113_01/
https://www.investmentmonitor.ai/tech/the-worlds-top-five-quantum-computing-hubs