The global defense and security landscape is evolving at an unprecedented pace, marked by intense competition across geopolitical, economic, military, technological, and industrial spheres. This competition, while driving innovation and development, also introduces significant security vulnerabilities and the potential for conflict.
Technology forecasting is a crucial tool for military planners, allowing them to anticipate future threats and opportunities. By understanding emerging technologies and their potential applications, military leaders can make informed decisions about investments, training, and doctrine. This article explores the current dynamics of global competition, the impact of emerging technologies, and the crucial role of technology forecasting in shaping future defense and security strategies.
The Changing Global Landscape
More and More physical spaces are now becoming militarized from deep oceans to the Arctic to Cislunar space up to the moon and technologies are being developed from surveillance, platforms, propulsion, materials to weapons for dominating these domains. Again, one of the chief motives is resource competition. For example, It is estimated that there are trillions of dollars worth of minerals and metals buried in asteroids that come close to the Earth hence there is race for asteroid mining. Similarly, as Global warming is melting the Arctic ice, it is opening up new shipping trade routes, and intense resource competition has started over an estimated $1 trillion untapped reserves of oil, natural gas and minerals.
The ongoing COVID-19 pandemic has highlighted the fierce global competition in various domains. Nations have leveraged the crisis for political and economic gains, with the U.S. accusing China of mishandling the outbreak while China engages in “vaccine diplomacy” to bolster its global standing. For example, Media outlets have linked the coronavirus outbreak to Biowarfare programs. This situation underscores the potential for exploitation and conflict arising from global crises.
Similarly, climate change continues to pose significant challenges such as frequent extreme weather events, such as heatwaves, droughts, floods, as well as disease outbreaks, food, and water security issues driving a competitive race toward renewable energy. The United States, China, and Europe are all vying to lead in clean energy technologies, aiming to mitigate climate change while transforming their economies.
Infrastructure development has also become a battleground. China’s Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) aims to secure economic, political, and military advantages through extensive infrastructure projects linking Asia with Europe and Africa. In response, the G7’s Build Back Better World (B3W) initiative seeks to offer an alternative, competitive approach.
Technological Competition and Forecasting
The race for dominance in emerging technologies has intensified among global superpowers, with the U.S., China, and Russia investing billions of dollars to secure economic and military advantages. This arms race extends beyond traditional weaponry into cutting-edge technologies like artificial intelligence (AI), robotics, and quantum computing. These advancements are not only shaping the future battlefield but also determining global leadership in economic and defense sectors. As countries pour resources into developing these technologies, military and defense planners must anticipate and navigate this rapidly evolving landscape to maintain strategic superiority.
AI, for example, is projected to generate $11 trillion in economic value over the next decade. In defense, AI is emerging as the most significant force multiplier, being integrated into virtually every aspect of military technology—from individual soldiers to expansive networked systems. This transformation is making entire military enterprises more intelligent, efficient, and effective. Whether in autonomous drones, predictive maintenance, or cybersecurity, AI is revolutionizing how militaries operate, making it a critical focus of technology forecasting efforts.
Similarly, quantum technologies, encompassing computing, cryptography, and sensing, are forecasted to grow into a $2.9 billion market by 2030. The military implications of quantum technology are vast, including breakthroughs in precision timing, sensors, and computational power. These advancements are set to impact not just defense but also sectors like aerospace, energy, and telecommunications. The race to develop a large-scale, programmable quantum computer is at the forefront, as the first to achieve this milestone will gain an immense economic and military edge.
In parallel, the competition extends to synthetic biology, which is poised to transform defense capabilities by enabling on-demand bioproduction of materials, fuels, sensors, and even food. Genome editing technologies could be harnessed to enhance biological systems, creating new forms of defense materials or even “super soldiers” equipped with enhanced physical and cognitive abilities. These innovations, driven by breakthroughs in biotechnology, represent a new frontier in the defense landscape, requiring precise and forward-looking forecasts to navigate the ethical and operational challenges they present.
Another critical aspect of military technology forecasting is the speed at which innovations can be exploited for military applications. Civil-military integration strategies are accelerating the process, with countries racing to harness emerging technologies and incorporate them into defense systems. The focus is not only on AI and quantum but also on advanced manufacturing techniques such as additive manufacturing (3D printing), which is revolutionizing the production of complex military equipment. From aerospace components to medical supplies and even entire structures, 3D printing offers the flexibility and efficiency needed to meet the evolving demands of modern warfare. Digital engineering methods are accelerating the development of military systems and weapons, emphasizing the need for ongoing adaptation to new technologies.
Globally, the race to dominate the Fourth Industrial Revolution, or Industry 4.0, is another critical driver of military technology forecasting. Countries like Germany, the U.S., Japan, and China are vying to lead this revolution, which promises the rise of “smart factories” capable of dramatically improving production efficiency. The defense sector will directly benefit from these advancements, particularly in aerospace and defense manufacturing, where the ability to produce cutting-edge systems faster and at a lower cost will offer significant strategic advantages.
Looking further ahead, AI is enabling what is now referred to as “intelligentized warfare,” where military confrontations will increasingly involve AI systems battling each other. This next evolution in warfare demands that militaries develop offensive and defensive AI capabilities to neutralize enemy systems while protecting their own. Additionally, warfare is entering the neuro-cognitive domain, where emerging technologies aim to influence and control the cognitive functions of soldiers and commanders, a new and complex frontier requiring robust forecasting and ethical considerations.
Looking further ahead, AI is enabling what is now referred to as “intelligentized warfare,” where military confrontations will increasingly involve AI systems battling each other. This next evolution in warfare demands that militaries develop offensive and defensive AI capabilities to neutralize enemy systems while protecting their own. Additionally, warfare is entering the neuro-cognitive domain, where emerging technologies aim to influence and control the cognitive functions of soldiers and commanders, a new and complex frontier requiring robust forecasting and ethical considerations.
One of the greatest challenges for defense science and technology (S&T) programs, such as those within the U.S. Department of Defense (DoD), is the avoidance of technological surprise. The exponential pace of discovery worldwide makes it critical for military planners to stay ahead of both advancements and threats. As the nature of military threats evolves, so too do the requirements for military technologies. Forecasting efforts must anticipate these changes to ensure that new technologies align with future operational needs.
Shaping an effective S&T portfolio for defense involves predicting technological developments well into the future. Military technology advances—such as the Global Positioning System (GPS), the proliferation of microprocessors, unmanned vehicles, and composite materials for armor—have all fundamentally transformed the battlefield. While some of these innovations were born from military R&D, others came from commercial sectors, highlighting the importance of forecasting across both domains. Military planners must remain vigilant in tracking advances in commercial technology and assessing their potential military applications.
Technology forecasting has become an essential tool not just for military establishments but for governments and corporations worldwide. More than 23 organizations globally provide technology forecasts as a primary service, with nearly all organizations engaging in some level of internal forecasting for strategic planning. For military institutions, technology forecasts guide procurement decisions, helping to determine which system developments and investments will provide the most significant future advantage. Missteps in forecasting can leave a military vulnerable to adversaries with superior technologies, much like a business that falls behind due to incorrect market predictions.
Technology Forecasting: Shaping the Future
In this rapidly evolving environment, technology forecasting is essential for anticipating future developments and making informed decisions. Forecasting helps identify emerging technologies that could impact defense and security, guiding investments and strategies to avoid technological surprises.
Technology forecasting involves predicting the characteristics and impact of future technologies based on current trends and historical data. For defense, this means assessing technologies’ readiness, growth potential, adoption rates, and criticality. Metrics such as patent applications, publications, mergers and acquisitions, venture capital investments, and public R&D interest are used to track and evaluate emerging technologies.
While most technology forecasts (performed for business purposes) are short term (the horizon is 1–5 years), the technology forecasts for the military in many cases (although there are many important exceptions) is either mid-term (6–10 years) or long term (11–30 years). The necessity of long-term forecasts in the world of military technology is dictated by long periods of time required for full development of some types of complex military systems. Unfortunately, it has become common for a major defense acquisition program to take on the order of two decades from concept development to initial operating capability. Even before that, it takes another 10 or more years to develop the necessary foundational science. That’s why a 20 year or longer horizon is often important for military technology forecasts for the purposes of military technology development and procurement, particularly in critical management decisions on allocating funds to long-term research topics.
What changes are likely in military technology over the next 20 years? This question is fascinating on its own terms. More importantly, answering it is crucial for making appropriate changes in U.S. and allied weaponry, military operations, wartime preparations, and defense budget priorities. To be sure, technology is advancing fast in many realms. Defense resource decisions need to be based on concrete analysis that breaks down the categories of major military technological invention and innovation one by one and examines each. Presumably, those areas where things are changing fastest may warrant the most investment, as well as the most creative thinking about how to modify tactics and operational plans to exploit new opportunities (and mitigate new vulnerabilities that adversaries may develop as a result of these same likely advances).
Technology forecasting attempts to predict the future characteristics of useful technological machines, procedures or techniques. Researchers create technology forecasts based on past experience and current technological developments. Like other forecasts, technology forecasting can be helpful for both public and private organizations to make smart decisions. By analyzing future opportunities and threats, the forecaster can improve decisions in order to achieve maximum benefit. Failure to forecast a technology (false negative) is just as serious as an incorrect forecast that a technology would appear. If a country fails to anticipate a critical military technology and fails to make appropriate investments, it may face a catastrophic surprise at the hands of an adversary who did acquire the technology.
The purpose of technological forecasting do not necessarily need to predict the precise form technology will take in a given application at some specific future date. Like any other forecasts, their purpose is simply to help evaluate the probability and significance of various possible future developments so that managers can make better decisions.
Key Factors Driving Military Technology Forecasting
- Geopolitical Dynamics: Shifts in global power structures and emerging threats drive the need for advanced military technologies. Forecasting helps predict how geopolitical changes might influence the development and deployment of new defense systems.
- Emerging Technologies: Advances in fields such as artificial intelligence, quantum computing, and synthetic biology have the potential to revolutionize military capabilities. Understanding these technologies’ trajectories helps military planners prepare for their implications.
- Budget Constraints: Defense budgets are often limited and must be allocated wisely. Forecasting helps prioritize investments in technologies that offer the greatest potential return on investment and strategic value.
- Innovation Cycles: Technology development often follows specific cycles of innovation. By analyzing these cycles, military organizations can anticipate when new technologies will mature and become operationally viable.
- Threat Landscape: The evolving nature of threats, from cyber warfare to unconventional tactics, necessitates continuous adaptation of military technologies. Forecasting helps anticipate new threat vectors and develop countermeasures.
Methodologies for Military Technology Forecasting
Several traditional metrics are commonly used to track and monitor emerging technologies. These include:
- Patent Applications: Tracking who is inventing new things and where innovations are emerging is critical. Patent activity can signal the areas of technological focus and innovation.
- Publications: Academic and industry journal articles provide insights into where research is concentrated and who the leading thinkers and innovators are.
- Mergers and Acquisitions (M&A): Examining which emerging startups are being acquired by larger companies can indicate what established firms see as future threats or opportunities.
- Venture Capital (VC): The flow of “smart money” into new technologies can offer a glimpse into what investors believe has the potential for exponential growth.
- Public R&D and Regulatory Interest: Government investments and regulations can provide clues about what technologies policymakers are betting on for future development.
- Hobbyist Interest: Enthusiasm from hobbyists and online communities (e.g., Reddit) can sometimes predict the grassroots excitement that drives early adoption.
Categories of Military Technologies
Additionally, several metrics are used to evaluate the viability and future potential of emerging technologies, such as:
- Technology Readiness Level (TRL): This measures the maturity of a technology and how close it is to full-scale deployment. Technology Readiness Assessments (TRAs) use a scale from 1 to 9 to measure technology maturity, with TRL 9 representing proven, operational systems. While TRL 9 is ideal, demonstrating technologies at TRL 8 can be sufficient for proof of existence and commercial availability.
- Potential for Growth: This evaluates whether a large market exists for the technology and its potential for future expansion.
- Potential for Adoption: This metric considers whether consumers or businesses will embrace the technology and integrate it into their operations.
- Speed of Growth/Adoption: This tracks whether a technology is poised for rapid, exponential adoption in the near future.
- Criticality: In some cases, being the first to adopt or develop a technology provides a significant advantage, especially in zero-sum markets where “winner takes all.”
While these metrics are highly useful, they each come with limitations. Some, like M&A activity databases, are paywalled and difficult for general users to access. Others, such as patent databases, are highly technical and require specialized knowledge to interpret. Metrics like criticality are qualitative, while assessments such as TRLs often require collaboration between multiple experts.
For individuals or organizations tracking emerging trends, particularly in complex fields like semiconductors, the key is to develop an ability to synthesize these seemingly disparate data points. By combining insights from various sources, it’s possible to identify emerging trends before they fully take shape. That’s what this post aims to explore.
- Trend Analysis: By examining historical data and current trends, analysts can identify patterns and project future developments. This method helps predict how existing technologies might evolve and what new technologies might emerge.
- Expert Panels: Engaging with experts and thought leaders in defense and technology fields provides valuable insights into future developments. Expert panels can offer forecasts based on their knowledge and experience.
- Scenario Planning: Creating and analyzing different scenarios helps understand how various factors might impact technological advancement. Scenario planning allows military organizations to prepare for multiple potential futures.
- Technology Roadmapping: This method involves creating a strategic plan that outlines the development and implementation timelines for key technologies. Roadmaps help align technology development with strategic goals and operational needs.
- Patent Analysis: Tracking patent filings and technological innovations provides insights into emerging technologies and their potential applications in the military domain.
Technology Convergence: A Strategic Approach for Military Innovation
Technology convergence is a vital concept in the development of future military capabilities, where different sciences and technologies merge to create groundbreaking advancements. Experts recommend a two-fold approach to achieving technology convergence: first, identify the desired outcomes and capabilities needed by the military at a specific point in the future, and then forecast the convergence of individual sciences and technologies that will enable these outcomes. This method involves clustering relevant sciences and technologies likely to converge and evolve along a common timeline, resulting in a roadmap for future capabilities.
Historically, early technology convergences have led to revolutionary advancements. For example, the invention of radar came from the convergence of electromagnetic radiation science with materials science, which led to the development of microwave generators and other essential devices. Similarly, modern wireless handheld devices, combined with the internet, trace their origins back to technological advancements in telephony and solid-state physics. The integration of fiber optics and computer technologies further enabled the global spread of broadband networks, showcasing how converging technologies can transform industries.
A similar convergence occurred in the life sciences, particularly in 1953, when Watson and Crick discovered the double-helix structure of DNA. This breakthrough resulted from the fusion of organic chemistry, physics, and information technology, leading to subsequent advances in genomics, protein sequencing, and molecular biology. These developments laid the groundwork for fields like proteomics and metabolomics, fundamentally reshaping modern medicine. This pattern of technological convergence demonstrates the importance of forecasting potential future intersections of science and technology, particularly for defense and security.
In today’s rapidly evolving landscape, the role of technology forecasting has been transformed by the exponential growth of computing power. For instance, a recent study by Northwestern University’s Institute on Complex Systems showed how artificial intelligence (AI) could predict which scientific studies would be most reproducible, aiding in the selection of promising innovations. AI and data-driven approaches are now critical in forecasting the convergence of emerging technologies and their potential impact on defense.
Military organizations, like the Army, can use technology convergence to identify emerging trends that will have a high impact in the short and mid-term. By supporting the development of these converging technologies, defense sectors can stay ahead of adversaries, ensuring that new systems, weapons, and strategies are aligned with future needs.
In conclusion, technology convergence offers a strategic framework for military innovation, allowing defense planners to anticipate and harness the power of multiple scientific disciplines. By focusing on the intersection of emerging technologies, the military can ensure it remains prepared to meet the challenges of tomorrow’s battlefield with enhanced precision, intelligence, and strength.
Case Studies: Military Technology Forecasting in Action
NATO, through its Innovation Hub, employs technology forecasting to stay ahead of emerging threats and maintain military superiority. The Innovation Hub focuses on anticipating the next wave of disruptive technologies that could reshape warfare, including autonomous systems, artificial intelligence, and advanced cyber capabilities. By collaborating with partner countries, industries, and research institutions, NATO can project how these technologies will evolve and what impact they might have on both offensive and defensive operations.
For instance, NATO has forecasted a future where unmanned systems and AI-driven decision-making play a central role in military strategy. This includes the development of autonomous weapons systems, cybersecurity measures, and AI-enhanced surveillance tools that will provide the Alliance with a strategic advantage in future conflicts. NATO’s forward-looking strategy emphasizes the convergence of different technologies to enhance collective defense and adapt to rapidly changing security landscapes.
The UK’s Defence Science and Technology Laboratory (Dstl) is tasked with identifying emerging technologies that will impact future military operations. Dstl conducts horizon scanning to predict advancements in fields such as quantum technology, AI, space systems, and synthetic biology, all of which are expected to
Technology forecasting has become a crucial tool for militaries worldwide to anticipate future threats, opportunities, and technological trends. Here are some key examples of its successful application:
1. United States Army
- Project Maven: Launched in 2017, Project Maven used artificial intelligence (AI) to analyze drone footage, identifying objects and potential targets with high accuracy. This project showcased how AI can enhance military operations, improving decision-making and intelligence gathering in real-time. It also forecasted AI’s growing role in autonomous systems and data-driven warfare.
- Future Combat Systems (FCS): Initiated in the early 2000s, the FCS program was an ambitious attempt to create a fully integrated, network-centric battlefield environment. Although the program was canceled in 2009, it highlighted the U.S. Army’s efforts to anticipate trends such as automation, sensor networks, and integrated communication systems, which have since been realized in programs like the Joint All-Domain Command and Control (JADC2).
2. Chinese Military
- J-20 Stealth Fighter: The development of the J-20 stealth fighter demonstrated China’s foresight in air warfare trends. Recognizing the importance of stealth technology in modern combat, China invested in the development of a next-generation fighter that could rival the capabilities of Western platforms like the F-22 and F-35. The J-20 is now a cornerstone of China’s air superiority ambitions.
- Artificial Intelligence: China has heavily invested in AI to transform military operations across various domains. AI is being used for tasks such as autonomous drone swarms, target recognition, logistics management, and cybersecurity. By focusing on AI, China has anticipated the future of warfare, where AI-driven systems will play a critical role in enhancing efficiency and reducing human error on the battlefield.
3. Russian Military
- Hypersonic Weapons: Russia’s development of hypersonic weapons like the Avangard and Zircon has showcased its ability to forecast shifts in global military balance. Hypersonic missiles, which travel at speeds greater than Mach 5, are difficult to intercept with current missile defense systems, giving Russia a strategic edge. This technology has the potential to reshape missile defense strategies worldwide.
- Cyber Warfare: Russia’s emphasis on cyber warfare as a key military strategy highlights its foresight in recognizing the significance of cyber operations. Russian cyberattacks, such as those on critical infrastructure and government institutions, underline the growing importance of offensive and defensive cyber capabilities. By investing in cyber warfare, Russia is preparing for future conflicts where digital combat may play as significant a role as physical warfare.
4. Israeli Military:
The Israel Defense Forces (IDF) rely heavily on technology forecasting to maintain their edge in a region with evolving threats. Israel has been proactive in identifying technological trends in areas like cybersecurity, missile defense, and autonomous systems. The IDF collaborates with local defense industries and academia to forecast future technologies that could enhance its operational capabilities.
- Iron Dome Missile Defense System: One of the most successful examples of technology forecasting in military defense, Israel’s Iron Dome was developed in response to anticipated rocket attacks from regional adversaries. The system’s capability to intercept and destroy short-range rockets in real time has proven indispensable, with a reported success rate of over 90%. It exemplifies how accurate forecasting of future threats can lead to lifesaving technologies.
- Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (UAVs): Israel has been a global leader in UAV development, particularly for military purposes such as reconnaissance, surveillance, and precision strikes. Early adoption and investment in UAV technology have allowed Israel to maintain a tactical advantage on the battlefield. The foresight to prioritize unmanned systems has revolutionized intelligence gathering and operational flexibility for the Israeli military.
These case studies illustrate how military organizations across the globe are leveraging technology forecasting to anticipate future trends and remain competitive. Whether in AI, cyber warfare, hypersonics, or unmanned systems, effective technology forecasting has helped militaries develop capabilities that ensure their readiness for the rapidly evolving nature of modern warfare. As emerging technologies continue to advance, the role of forecasting in military planning will become even more critical.
The Future of Technology Forecasting
As technology continues to advance rapidly, forecasting becomes increasingly important. AI and other emerging technologies will shape future defense and security landscapes, necessitating continuous adaptation and investment. By understanding and predicting technological trends, military leaders and planners can make strategic decisions that ensure readiness and maintain a competitive edge.
In conclusion, navigating the future of defense and security requires a keen understanding of global competition, emerging technologies, and the critical role of technology forecasting. By staying ahead of technological trends and anticipating future developments, nations can better prepare for and address the evolving challenges of the modern world.