International Defense Security & Technology Your trusted Source for News, Research and Analysis
As the world grapples with energy security, climate change, and the increasing demand for cleaner, more reliable power sources, nuclear energy is once again gaining prominence. Not only has it proven to be a low-carbon energy option, but it is also being positioned as a critical player in the next generation of energy technologies—particularly nuclear fusion. To unlock the full potential of both nuclear fission and fusion, countries worldwide are investing in the development of new nuclear materials that promise to improve reactor safety, enhance economic viability, and enable the realization of fusion energy.
Nuclear Energy as a Solution
In recent years, a growing consensus among climate scientists and policymakers has emerged that nuclear energy is essential for reducing carbon emissions and combating global warming. Unlike fossil fuels, nuclear power produces minimal GHG emissions while delivering high energy output, making it a strong candidate for meeting the world’s energy needs in a cleaner and more sustainable way. Many countries and states have shifted from Renewable Energy Mandates to technology-neutral Clean Energy Standards, which include nuclear energy as a critical component of their decarbonization strategies.
Nuclear power offers high energy density and a low carbon footprint, and the international community has decades of experience in its use. Despite these advantages, nuclear power has not yet dominated the global energy mix, primarily due to safety concerns, waste management issues, and the threat of nuclear proliferation. The challenges of handling radioactive waste, ensuring operational safety, and preventing the misuse of nuclear materials for weapons have hampered the broader adoption of nuclear power.
Nuclear Energy: Principles and Types
Nuclear energy is harnessed through two primary processes: nuclear fission and nuclear fusion, each with distinct principles and methods.
Nuclear Fission involves splitting heavy atomic nuclei into smaller, lighter nuclei, releasing a significant amount of energy in the form of heat. This process serves as the foundation for most conventional nuclear reactors. In a fission reaction, a heavy nucleus, such as uranium-235 or plutonium-239, absorbs a neutron and becomes unstable. This instability causes it to split into smaller fragments, releasing additional neutrons and a substantial amount of energy. The energy generated from fission is used to heat water, producing steam that drives turbines to generate electricity. The main types of nuclear fission reactors include Pressurized Water Reactors (PWRs), which keep water under pressure to prevent it from boiling, allowing it to absorb more heat from the reactor core; Boiling Water Reactors (BWRs), where water is allowed to boil and the resulting steam drives the turbines directly; and Heavy Water Reactors (HWRs), which use heavy water (deuterium oxide) as a moderator to slow down neutrons and enable the use of natural uranium as fuel.
Nuclear Fusion, in contrast, involves combining light atomic nuclei to form a heavier nucleus, releasing vast amounts of energy in the process. This reaction mirrors the mechanisms that power the Sun, offering the promise of providing a nearly limitless source of clean energy on Earth. Fusion typically occurs between isotopes of hydrogen, such as deuterium and tritium. The two main methods to achieve fusion are Magnetic Confinement Fusion (MCF) and Inertial Confinement Fusion (ICF). MCF utilizes powerful magnetic fields to confine a superheated plasma of hydrogen isotopes within a controlled environment. Devices such as tokamaks and stellarators are central to this approach; tokamaks feature a doughnut-shaped chamber, while stellarators employ twisted magnetic field lines for enhanced stability. On the other hand, ICF involves compressing a small pellet of fusion fuel to extremely high pressures and temperatures using intense lasers or other energy sources, triggering fusion reactions. Facilities like the National Ignition Facility (NIF) are leading research efforts in this area.
Both nuclear fission and fusion have their unique advantages and challenges. While fission technology is well-established and currently used for electricity generation worldwide, fusion represents a future potential source of clean, virtually limitless energy. However, achieving practical fusion energy requires overcoming significant technical barriers, making it a focal point of ongoing research and development in the field of nuclear energy.
Why New Nuclear Materials Are Critical
The safe and economical operation of any nuclear power system relies to a great extent, on the success of the fuel and the materials of construction. During the lifetime of a nuclear power system which currently can be as long as 60 years, the materials are subject to high temperature, a corrosive environment, and damage from high-energy particles released during fission. The fuel which provides the power for the reactor has a much shorter life but is subject to the same types of harsh environments. Understanding and overcoming material degradation in an extreme environment is essential for safe, efficient operation. New advanced materials may make plant construction more economical. Materials science plays a pivotal role in extending the life of existing nuclear reactors; in deploying new, modern light water reactors, advanced reactors with non-water coolants, and small modular reactors; and in storing, recycling, and disposing of used nuclear fuel.
A typical Light Water Reactor (LWR) relies on a diverse array of materials that must all function effectively under demanding conditions. For existing LWRs, extending the lifespan of each fuel element is crucial. Doing so would enhance energy extraction from the fuel, as approximately 95% of the energy content remains unused by the end of a typical fuel pin’s life cycle. By optimizing fuel utilization, operators could reduce waste and significantly improve the overall economics of nuclear power generation. This improvement is vital for maximizing the efficiency of LWRs and minimizing the environmental impact associated with spent fuel management.
For fusion energy to become commercially viable, materials must be developed that can withstand prolonged exposure to high-energy neutron fluxes while maintaining structural integrity and performance. These advancements are not only key to improving the safety and economics of existing nuclear reactors but also crucial for realizing the potential of fusion technology. By pushing the boundaries of material science, countries can pave the way toward a future where fusion energy offers a near-limitless and clean energy source for generations to come.
Key Innovations in New Nuclear Materials
Several key innovations are emerging in the field of nuclear materials, poised to reshape the future of nuclear energy. One of the most significant advancements is the development of Accident-Tolerant Fuels (ATFs). These fuels are specifically engineered to maintain their structural integrity even under extreme accident scenarios. By reducing the likelihood of core meltdowns, ATFs significantly enhance reactor safety, making them a crucial component in modernizing nuclear energy systems.
Another promising innovation is the use of High-Entropy Alloys (HEAs). Comprising multiple principal elements, HEAs exhibit exceptional radiation resistance, thermal stability, and mechanical strength. These properties make HEAs highly suitable for next-generation reactors, where materials must withstand the harsh conditions of nuclear environments without degrading over time. This advancement could lead to more reliable and efficient reactor designs.
Self-Healing Materials represent another groundbreaking development in nuclear materials technology. Researchers are focusing on creating materials that can autonomously repair themselves after experiencing radiation damage. This capability could dramatically extend the operational lifespan of nuclear reactors, particularly in fusion systems, where the extreme conditions can cause rapid degradation of conventional materials.
Lastly, the innovation of Reduced-Activation Steels is addressing a critical issue in nuclear waste management. These steels are designed to become less radioactive over time, which not only mitigates the long-term challenges associated with nuclear waste but also enhances the sustainability of nuclear energy. By improving the longevity and safety of reactor components, these advancements are paving the way for a more sustainable future in nuclear power.
In addition to advancements in fusion technology, nuclear fission also greatly relies on innovative materials. The performance and safety of fission reactors depend on materials that can withstand high temperatures and intense neutron radiation. For instance, materials used in fuel assemblies, cladding, and structural components must demonstrate exceptional corrosion resistance and mechanical strength. Innovations in ATFs and HEAs, in particular, play a crucial role in enhancing the efficiency and safety of fission reactors. By developing and implementing these advanced materials, the nuclear fission industry can reduce the risk of accidents and improve the overall sustainability of nuclear energy.
The Leading Nations in Nuclear Material Development
Scientists have made significant progress in developing fusion reactor materials, including nanocomposite solids and engineered alloys. For instance, researchers from Texas A&M University and Los Alamos National Laboratory have discovered that helium, a byproduct of fusion reactions, can form vein-like channels in nanocomposite materials rather than damaging them. These findings could lead to the development of helium-resistant materials capable of withstanding the harsh environment inside fusion reactors. Several countries are leading the charge in nuclear material development, each contributing uniquely to the future of nuclear energy.
1. United States: Advanced Materials for Next-Gen Reactors
The United States is deeply invested in nuclear material research, driven by its energy needs and national security concerns. Key institutions like Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) and Argonne National Laboratory (ANL) are spearheading efforts to develop materials that are more resistant to radiation damage and corrosion.
Focus Areas:
- Accident-Tolerant Fuels (ATFs): The U.S. is working on ATFs that enhance safety in light-water reactors by incorporating materials like silicon carbide cladding and advanced fuel compositions. These innovations are designed to prevent the release of radioactive materials during accidents.
- High-Entropy Alloys (HEAs): HEAs are being explored for their exceptional resistance to radiation damage and heat. These materials hold promise for both fission and fusion reactors.
- Fusion Materials: Research is underway to create materials capable of withstanding the extreme neutron fluxes in fusion reactors. The U.S. is particularly focused on developing self-healing materials that can repair radiation damage at the atomic level.
Department of Energy (DOE) has continued to advance the development of new metal alloys through engineered nanostructures, with a focus on enhancing plasma-facing materials for fusion reactors. Tungsten remains a leading candidate due to its high melting point and low sputtering yield; however, its effectiveness is limited by challenges such as stability against recrystallization, oxidation resistance, and radiation tolerance. To tackle these issues, Trelewicz secured a $750,000 five-year award from the DOE’s Early Career Research Program to innovate stable nanocrystalline tungsten alloys designed to withstand the extreme environments of fusion reactors.
Currently, Trelewicz’s research combines cutting-edge simulations of atomic interactions with experimental techniques that involve real-time ion irradiation and mechanical testing. This approach seeks to uncover the underlying mechanisms that influence the thermal stability and radiation tolerance of these advanced materials. Utilizing high-performance computing resources like the HPC cluster at the Center for Functional Nanomaterials (CFN) and Titan at the Oak Ridge Leadership Computing Facility, his team conducts large-scale atomistic simulations to inform alloy design. Recently, Trelewicz’s students made a significant discovery regarding a metastable-to-stable phase transition in thin films of nanostructured tungsten, which alters grain growth processes. By introducing chromium and titanium into tungsten, they successfully eliminated the metastable phase, enhancing the material’s thermal stability and bringing us closer to developing more resilient alloys for future fusion energy applications.
2019: Tiny Granules Aid Stabilization in Fusion Power
In 2019, researchers from the U.S. Department of Energy’s Princeton Plasma Physics Laboratory (PPPL) and General Atomics revealed that injecting tiny beryllium pellets into the ITER fusion facility could help stabilize plasma and enhance fusion reactions. Experiments and computer simulations demonstrated that these pellets could trigger small eruptions, known as edge-localized modes (ELMs), which prevent larger eruptions that can damage the reactor. The team also tested similar light metals—carbon, lithium, and boron carbide—at the DIII-D National Fusion Facility, confirming that their properties could effectively mimic beryllium’s impact on ITER plasma. This granule injection technique promises to extend the lifespan of ITER components by mitigating the risks posed by larger ELMs, a critical step toward achieving stable and sustainable fusion energy.
May 2020: Approval of Alloy 617 for High-Temperature Nuclear Plants
In May 2020, the American Society of Mechanical Engineers approved Alloy 617 for use in high-temperature nuclear reactors, marking a significant advancement in reactor material technology. Developed through a decade-long collaboration among various U.S. national laboratories, Alloy 617 combines nickel, chromium, cobalt, and molybdenum, offering superior performance at operating temperatures up to 1,750°F—nearly 400 degrees hotter than previously approved materials. This new alloy not only enhances design flexibility for advanced nuclear systems but also opens opportunities for utilizing nuclear energy in applications such as community heating, industrial processes, hydrogen production, and water purification, all while reducing carbon emissions. The approval process involved extensive testing and $15 million in funding from the Department of Energy, highlighting the commitment to advancing nuclear technology for the future.
2. European Union: A Collaborative Approach
The European Union (EU) has embraced a cooperative strategy in nuclear material development through initiatives like the European Materials Modelling Council and the European Fusion Development Agreement (EFDA). Much of the EU’s fusion research is centered on ITER, the global fusion project based in France.
Focus Areas:
- Tungsten and Reduced-Activation Steels: Tungsten, with its high melting point and low sputtering yield, is being considered for plasma-facing components in fusion reactors. Reduced-activation steels are being developed to minimize radioactive waste in fusion applications.
- Multi-scale Modeling: The EU applies advanced computational techniques to predict how materials will behave under nuclear conditions, accelerating development and ensuring materials meet safety and regulatory standards.
3. China: Pushing the Boundaries of Fusion Materials
China is quickly emerging as a leader in nuclear technology, particularly in materials for fusion reactors. The Chinese government has heavily invested in the China Fusion Engineering Test Reactor (CFETR), a project aimed at validating key materials for future fusion plants.
Focus Areas:
- Graphite and Carbon-Based Composites: These materials are being studied for their ability to withstand the extreme conditions inside fusion reactors. Graphite’s ability to handle high temperatures without melting makes it a material of interest.
- Advanced Ceramics: China is exploring ceramics capable of enduring high neutron radiation and thermal stresses. These lightweight materials are resistant to radiation damage and have low thermal conductivity.
China aims to lead in commercial fusion energy by the 2050s, positioning itself as a global innovator in clean energy.
4. Japan: Pioneering Low-Activation Materials
Japan has long been a leader in nuclear materials research, making significant contributions to both fission and fusion technologies. Its focus is on developing low-activation materials to reduce radioactive waste in fusion reactors.
Focus Areas:
- Vanadium Alloys: Japan is investigating vanadium-based alloys for structural components in fusion reactors. These alloys are resistant to neutron radiation and generate fewer radioactive byproducts, which can significantly lower the environmental impact of fusion.
- Self-Healing Materials: Japan is also advancing research into self-healing alloys that could extend the lifespan of reactor components by autonomously repairing neutron-induced damage.
Japan’s research plays a crucial role in reducing operational and decommissioning costs for future fusion reactors, making them more economically viable for widespread use.
5. Russia
In recent developments, Russian researchers from the National Research Nuclear University MEPhI have explored the use of isotopically modified molybdenum as a promising alternative to zirconium alloys in nuclear fuel-element casings. While zirconium alloys have long been favored for their high corrosion resistance and low thermal neutron capture cross-section, they also pose significant risks, including hydrogen production during high-temperature reactions, which contributed to the Fukushima Daiichi nuclear disaster in 2011. Molybdenum alloys, with superior thermal conductivity, present a safer option, but have historically been costly due to the need for enriched uranium. However, the team has discovered a method to modify the natural isotopic composition of molybdenum using centrifugal separation technology, potentially lowering production costs and maintaining favorable thermal neutron capture properties. This innovative approach could significantly enhance the safety of nuclear reactors, representing a crucial step toward more reliable and efficient nuclear energy systems today. The study, published in Chemical Engineering Research and Design, emphasizes the collaboration between Russian and Chinese researchers and highlights ongoing advancements in nuclear safety technology.
A groundbreaking discovery by researchers at Los Alamos National Laboratory, led by Demkowicz, has the potential to revolutionize materials for nuclear fusion by creating helium-resistant nanocomposites. Their study, published in Science Advances, revealed that instead of forming damaging bubbles, helium in these materials develops long, interconnected channels resembling a vascular system found in living tissues. This unexpected behavior allows helium to flow out of fusion reactors rather than becoming trapped, which is crucial for maintaining the integrity of reactor components. Demkowicz envisions broader applications for this innovative design, suggesting that such vascularized solids could facilitate the transport of heat, electricity, or even chemicals that promote self-healing capabilities. This breakthrough not only moves us closer to making fusion energy a practical reality but also opens up exciting possibilities for advanced materials across various fields.
The Road to Commercial Nuclear Fusion
Fusion energy represents the ultimate goal for many of these material research programs. Unlike fission, which splits heavy atomic nuclei, fusion combines light nuclei (usually isotopes of hydrogen) to release energy. This process has the potential to provide virtually limitless, clean energy with minimal waste and no greenhouse gas emissions.
However, achieving commercial nuclear fusion requires breakthroughs in materials science. The extreme conditions inside a fusion reactor—plasma temperatures exceeding 100 million degrees Celsius and neutron bombardment—demand materials that can handle these stresses without degrading.
ITER, along with China’s CFETR, the U.S.’s SPARC, and the EU’s DEMO (Demonstration Fusion Power Plant), is testing these new materials in experimental setups, with the hope of having a working fusion reactor by the 2030s.
International Collaboration
Nuclear energy research is a global endeavor, with collaborations among countries leading to advancements in both fission and fusion technologies. The International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) has launched initiatives to develop materials for fusion reactors, which are essential for realizing the dream of commercial fusion power plants. While commercial fusion energy is still years away, research efforts are paving the way for future breakthroughs.
In the meantime, nuclear fission will continue to play a critical role in the global energy landscape. Advancements in materials science, safety protocols, and reactor designs are making nuclear power safer and more efficient. With continued investment in nuclear research and development, nuclear energy could become a cornerstone of global efforts to reduce carbon emissions and combat climate change.
Conclusion: The Future of Nuclear Energy
The development of new nuclear materials is at the heart of the next revolution in nuclear energy. Whether it’s improving the safety and efficiency of current fission reactors or making fusion energy a reality, these materials hold the key to overcoming the most significant challenges in the nuclear field. With countries around the world spearheading research into advanced materials like HEAs, low-activation steels, and self-healing alloys, the future of nuclear energy looks increasingly promising—ushering in a new era of safer, more economical, and sustainable power.
References and resources also include:
https://www.energy.gov/ne/articles/new-alloy-material-approved-use-high-temperature-nuclear-plants
