India has been a target of many cyber attacks, cyber espionage and cyber warfare with fingers often pointing towards China and Pakistan. India was the third worst hit nation by ransomware WannaCry as more than 40,000 computers were affected even though no major corporate or bank reported disruption to their activities. Estimated 1,44,496 cyber security attacks observed in the country during 2014-16.
On the other hand the commitment of india towards cybersecurity measures remain inadequate. As per the findings of the Global Cybersecurity Index 2017 (GCI) released by the UN telecommunications agency International Telecommunication Union (ITU), India ranks 23 out of the 193 member countries when it comes to commitment to cybersecurity. Singapore has topped a global cyber security index released by the United Nations, followed by other UN member states such as the United States, Malaysia, Oman, Estonia, Mauritius, Australia, Georgia, France and Canada, the other top 10 countries.
Most organisations lack a cybersecurity strategy, while for a large majority cybersecurity was an afterthought. About 59 per cent (three in five) respondents said the fear of cyber-attacks has hindered digital transformation projects,” the study noted. The study also examined the current cyber security strategy of organisations in India. It found that nine in 10 (92 per cent) Indian organisations are looking to leverage Artificial Intelligence (AI) to enhance their cyber security strategy. Additionally, more than one in five (22 per cent) of Indian organisations have witnessed benefits of using AI to achieve faster and more accurate detection of threats.
India has now stepped up its cyber security preparedness by enunciating and implementing its National Cyber Security Policy 2013 and promoting various measures. Ministry of Defense (MoD) is now set to establish the defense Cyber Agency, among the three new tri-service agencies to outstand on the grounds of cyber welfare, space, and special operations. The defense Cyber Agency, along with space agencies will launch on May, in the capital city, Delhi, as per the clearance given by PM Modi, during the Combined Commanders’ Conference in Jodhpur .
It is set to incorporate as many as 1000 personnel from all the three disciplines of defense – Army, Navy, and IAF. It has many a time been reported that cyber threats coming in from all around the world have started increasing at an exponential rate. At such a time, India is required to be equipped with technological skills and backup to combat the same. Understanding the criticalities of such cyber security, the foundation has set up a task force headed by Lt. Gen. Davinder Kumar (retired) to suggest a road map for the same.
The ministry has already created a new wing — Cyber and Information Security Division — to check radicalisation and cyber fraud as part of a major rejig of some of its crucial wings. The new wing, CIS, has been created to monitor online crimes and threats, including cyber fraud and hacking, and suggest ways to minimise and fight them. This division will track and counter online fraud, hacking, identity theft, dark net, trafficking and cyber attacks on critical information infrastructure, the officials said.
The Union Home Ministry is planning to set up an apex coordination centre and has asked states to establish a similar mechanism in every district. It has also released Rs 83 crore for setting up of a cyber forensic training laboratory-cum-training centre for police officials in each state. The cyber crime cases are of varied types. These range from defacement of government websites, online financial frauds, online stalking and harassment, and data thefts. Each requires specialised investigative skill sets and forensic tools,” another official said. The apex centre — Indian Cyber Crime Coordination Centre (I4C) — would be set up in Delhi. It would coordinate with state governments and union territories, and closely monitor the cyber space and social media with due emphasis on vernacular content.
India has also been target from many cyber warfare campaigns. In one instance, according to the Toronto based Munk Centre of International Studies, GhostNet — a Chinese network, had infiltrated networks of the Indian Government as well as of the Dalai Lama. The elite National Security Guard’s website was reportedly defaced with profanity-laden messages for Prime Minister Narendra Modi last month.
Tensions ratcheted up in South Asia following the Pulwama suicide bombing against Indian police forces on February 14 and India’s retaliatory strikes against Pakistan. India launched Operation Hangover that has targeted Pakistan and, in response, Pakistan spearheaded Operation Arachnophobia, which sought to obtain intelligence from Indian officials.
India has moved a step closer to dealing with contemporary and new threats with the Cabinet Committee on Security recently clearing the formation of three agencies, the Defence Cyber Agency, the Defence Space Agency and the Special Operation Division, a government official familiar with the matter said on condition of anonymity. All three will be tri-service agencies, which means they will draw from each service and serve under the command of the Chairman, Chief of Staff Committee, a second official confirmed.
India the prime target of Cyber Attacks
India has been the target of over 4.3 lakh cyber attacks from five countries including China, Russia and the US while more than 73,000 attacks were initiated from India between January and June 2018, says a Finnish cybersecurity company. Russia accounted for most cyber attacks on India (255,589), followed by the US (103,458), China (42,544), the Netherlands (19,169) and 15,330 attacks from Germany. The relatively higher number of inbound attacks on Indian honeypots reflects how the fast-digitising country is becoming more lucrative for global cyber criminals,” Leszek Tasiemski, Vice President of cyber security products R&D at F-Secure, said in a statement on Sunday.
Over 53 , 000 cyber security incidents like phishing, website intrusions and defacements, virus and ransomware attacks were observed in the country during 2017. As per the information reported to and tracked by Indian Computer Emergency Response Team (CERT- In ),cyber security incidents have been steadily increasing from a total number of 44,679, to 49,455, 50,362 and 53 ,081 during the year 2014, 2015, 2016 and 2017 , respectively. IT Minister Ravi Shankar Prasad said in a written reply to the Rajya Sabha that the types of cyber security incidents included phishing, scanning/probing, website intrusions and defacements, virus/malicious code, ransomware and denial of service attacks etc.
A cyber security firm Quick Heal Technologies said it has detected over 48,000 MS-17- 010 Shadow Broker exploit hits responsible for ‘WannaCry ransomware’ outbreak in India with West Bengal witnessing the most incidents. Ransomware attacks increasingly affected businesses and consumers, with indiscriminate campaigns pushing out massive volumes of malicious emails. Attackers are demanding more and more from victims, with the average ransom demand rising to over 1,000 USD in 2016, up from approximately 300 USD a year earlier.
On May 17, the cyber-security firm Symantec stated in a blog post that it had traced breaches of several Indian organisations to a cyber-espionage group called Suckfly. The targeted systems belonged to the central government, a large financial institution, a vendor to the largest stock exchange and an e-commerce company. The espionage activity began in April 2014 and continued through 2015, Symantec said. Another cyber-security firm, Kaspersky Lab, announced that it too had tracked at least one cyberespionage group, called Danti, that had penetrated Indian government systems through India’s diplomatic entities.
A large-sized enterprise in India loses an average of $10.3 million owing to cyber-attacks and a mid-sized organisation an average of $11,000 annually, said a Microsoft-led study said in Dec 2018. Cyber security attacks have also resulted in job losses across different functions in more than three in five (64 per cent) organisations that have experienced cyber-attacks, revealed the Frost and Sullivan study commissioned by Microsoft. Companies face the risk of significant financial loss, damage to customer satisfaction and market reputation-as is evident from high-profile breaches this year,” said Keshav Dhakad, Group Head and Assistant General Counsel, Corporate, External & Legal Affairs (CELA), Microsoft India.
Rapid digitisation in all sectors in India is making the country critically prone to targeted cyber attacks and ‘WannaCry’ ransomware attack is “just the tip of the iceberg”, according to cyber intelligence security company. The vulnerability of Indian critical infrastructure is further increasing with increasingly networking of the country under Digital India including transportation networks, power grids and financial institutions through on-line integration, with more and more official data stored on-line.
“Owing to the government initiatives and efforts, coupled with booming penetration of smartphones, PCs and high-speed internet access, the challenges associated with such attacks amplify significantly — making India one of the hot favourite destinations for a targeted cyber attack,” Israel-based Vital Intelligence Group said in a statement.
According to many cyber experts, several Indian companies and some government institutions have seen recently an increase in cyber attacks originating in China.Like in the case of the infrastructure company, these attacks are often carried out through difficult to-trace proxy servers in North Korea, Africa, Eastern Europe and Russia. Unlike a normal attack, the Chinese breaches tend to exploit vulnerabilities of Indian IT systems and “just observe.”
Large hardware imports from China is also leads to growing threat of hardware attacks through malicious insertion of malware or kill switch. Malware is a software which is designed to disrupt, damage, or gain access to a computer system There are reports that the Chinese have introduced malware or hidden software in Android phones and other hardware for surveillance, making it almost impossible for the user to detect any anomaly.
“The recent attacks strengthens the point that the biggest existential threat that is out there is cyber. It is evident that the world is already engaged in a 24×7 conflict with anonymous soldiers who are extremely difficult to trace,” said Marc Kahlberg, CEO and MD of Vital Intelligence Group. The group noted that “one size fits all approach” can never be the solution to curb the increasing cyber attacks and a constant vigil is the only solution to stay ahead in the race with the intruders.
“Just like the traditional battlefield, there is no one correct strategy, no short term solution and no silver-bullet to win a war. But awareness, understanding and vigilance combined with accurate targeted offensive frontline cyber intelligence will go a long way to keep the enemy busy and protect all of our cyber interests,” added Kahlberg.
India’s cyber security Initiatives
Indian government unveiled a National Cyber Security Policy 2013 on 2 July 2013, with vision to build a secure and resilient cyberspace for citizens, business and government and also to protect anyone from intervening into your privacy. The mission is to protect information and information infrastructure in cyberspace, build capabilities to prevent and respond to cyber threat, reduce vulnerabilities and minimize damage from cyber incidents through a combination of institutional structures, people, processes, technology and cooperation.
Recognising the strategic dimensions of cyberspace, the Prime Minister’s Office (PMO) created the position of the National Cyber Security Coordinator in 2014 to implement the policy. In India, cyberspace is being looked after primarily by the National Technical Research Organization (NTRO) operating under R&AW. Other top layer of agencies performing cyber operations are the National Intelligence Grid, and the National Information Board.
To ensure Internet security, Computer Emergency Response Team (CERT-IN) was established by Government of India in 2004 that reports Forecast & alerts on Cyber incidents, issuing of guidelines on Cyber incidents etc. occurring in India. In addition, the National Critical Information Infrastructure Centre (NCIIC) carved out CERT in 2013 is to protect assets in critical sectors like energy, banking, defence, telecom, transportation etc. The NSA is to oversee a public-private partnership to set up a cyber-security architecture..
Security testing: For testing IT products, there are some 10 setups for STQC (Standardisation, Testing and Quality Certification) across the country.
Tata Communications’ new Cyber Security Response Centre (CSRC)
Tata Communications’ new Cyber Security Response Centre (CSRC) was launched in Chennai in Sep 2018, the fourth for the company with other centres operating in Pune, Dubai, and Singapore. At the cyber response centre, Tata monitors traffic flows and tries to detect a variety of different attacks, such as phishing or malware, botnets and more.
“We do this using a combination of commercial feeds, open source data, and our own honeypot servers,” said Avinash Prasad, vice president, managed security services for Tata Communications. Honeypot servers are designed to look like they have sensitive data, and entice malicious attacks, in order to identify potential threats.
“People with the right cyber security skills are in short supply,” Tata Communication’s Chief Technology Officer, Srinivasan said. “That is why we are working with universities, and have been collaborating with the Sastra university to set up a cyber security lab.” “There is a significant skill gap in the market, where people who are studying aren’t in sync with the needs of the industry,” Srinivasan added. “We are trying to do guest lectures, and set up internship programs, so that people come into the industry with the required skills.”
India target of Cyber warfare campaigns
Cyber warfare has developed into a more sophisticated type of combat between countries, where you can destroy critical infrastructure such as power, telecommunications or banking by damaging the computer systems that control those infrastructures. It’s widely acknowledged that offensive cyberattacks will be a necessary component of any future military campaign, and the extreme cyberweapons are being developed now.
In early September 2016, Some 22,000 pages of data related to India’s top secret Scorpene submarine program were published online. This presumed data breach brought the issue of cyber security into the headlines. Indian Army may face serious cyber attacks from non-state actors in Pakistan, on its critical Information Infrastructure say, the Oil and Natural Gas Corporation of Electric grids.
Pakistan has unleashed a cyber war against India on social media, Over 1000 videos supporting Jehad in Kashmir have been created and several thousand anti India posts in social media have been shared in the last six months. They are both soft toned as well as radical videos, some arousing sympathy for victims, others arousing hatred against armed forces.
Cyber Agency and Cyber command
Many countries starting with US and which now includes U.K., China, Russia, Israel and others are setting up Unified cyber commands for more effective and coordinated efforts for conducting cyberspace operations , both offensive and defensive. The offensive operations are seen as deterrent to adversaries. US, Russia and China are also implementing various defence measures to protect their classified networks from Cyber Warfare.
In a bid to enhance its combat capabilities in the virtual domain, the defence ministry is working towards establishing a new cyber agency to tackle attempts by Chinese and Pakistani hackers to break into its systems and networks. “The tri-services integrated defence staff (IDS) is coming up with a unit to tackle the cyber warfare domain and it will be staffed with personnel from all the three services,” senior government sources told Mail Today.
“The forces have already started pooling in their resources in the cyber domain under the new agency, which would be headed by a major general-rank officer. The organisation will have both offensive and defensive capabilities in cyber warfare,” said the sources. Cyber arsenal shall serve as the key function of strategic deterrence. Till now, the army, navy and air force have their own separate cells dealing with cyber issues and they have also developed individual networks for safe communication and data exchange.
The information networks created by the forces are state of the art and are capable of detecting any violation at centralised locations within a few microseconds. “If anybody puts in a pen drive in a computer of the military network, our men sitting in Delhi and other centralised locations can detect it within no time and prevent any leakage or attack immediately,” said the sources.
“This step of creating a new cyber agency, which would be a precursor to a cyber command, is in the right direction. Now the focus should be on creating infrastructure for manufacturing totally indigenous information and communication technology equipment,” said information warfare expert Pavithran Rajan.
To test its capabilities, the new agency has also carried out its first cyber warfare exercise under which Indian forces carried out attacks on their own networks to check for loopholes and steps required to strengthen the system, the sources informed.
“The forces deduced that cyber should be the first agency to be raised for dealing with the increasing instances of attacks on military networks and systems,” they said.
The command of the new agency would be on rotational basis for the three services, which means that if it is first headed by an army officer, he would be succeeded by navy and air force officers. The head of the unit would report to the chief of integrated defence staff Lt Gen Satish Dua who heads the organisation at present.
Cyber Range Centre at IIDT to train cyber warriors
The International Institute of Digital Technologies (IIDT) in Tirupati is planning to establish a Cyber Range Centre to impart training to students in thwarting cyber attacks. “eSF Labs, which is the technology partner for GFSU, is setting up the Cyber Range Centre,” according to J.A. Chowdary, IT Adviser to the Chief Minister.
“At present, phishing, cyber frauds, ransomware, malicious domains, data thefts, and mobile frauds are posing a threat to the country. We have to prepare lakhs of cyber security warriors to protect from malwares,” he said.
“The IIDT students will be trained in tackling all kinds of cyber security threats. The proposed high-end Cyber Range Centre will provide a real-time environment on how to detect and thwart cyber attacks. Discussions will be held with cyber experts, researchers, and students on the subject,” said Mr. Chowdary.
A cyber partnership can be critical for India to meet its immediate goals in securing its cyber infrastructure and expanding opportunities for the country’s tech sector. Looking forward to becoming a secure cyber ecosystem, India has joined hands with several developed countries like the United States, Singapore, Japan, etc. These agreements will help India to challenge even more sophisticated cyber threats.
Indian and US officials also met in Washington in August 2015 at the whole-of-government cyber dialogue to discuss enhanced cyber security information sharing, cyber incident management and cyber security cooperation in the context of ‘Make in India’. In Jan 2017, India and the US have signed a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) for close cooperation and exchange of information pertaining to cyber security. The MoU between Indian Computer Emergency Response Team (CERT-In) and US CERT was signed by Electronics and IT Secretary Aruna Sundararajan and Richard Verma, the US Ambassador to India.
With Narendra Modi’s three-day state visit to Israel –India and Israel in their joint statement have committed to promote security and stability in cyberspace – with the possibility of exploring bilateral ties between their respective governments and businesses.
R&D in Cyber Security
Research and development of indigenous cyber security solutions are promoted through sponsored projects at autonomous R&D organisations. The programme facilitates basic research, technology demonstration, proof of concept, R&D test bed projects, prototypes and skill enhancement of manpower, in the thrust areas identified. Thrust Areas are Cryptography and Cryptanalysis, Network and Systems Security, Security Architectures, Vulnerability Detection and Analysis, Monitoring, Surveillance and Forensics. Encouraging cybersecurity in the country, the government of India has offered a fund of 5 crores to companies that work for the research and revolution of cybersecurity.
Indian Military testing its own indigenous operating system
In his maiden address to the senior commanders of the three services, the prime minister had asked them to guard against the threats in the cyber domain and after that, Army’s Jammu and Kashmir-based Northern Command started the evaluation of the indigenous operating system for military requirements.
‘The Northern Command has been evaluating the BOSS at its headquarters as an option for replacing the foreign solutions to provide more security to the critical security-related information of the forces deployed there,’ government sources told Mail Today.
BOSS is a software developed to benefit the usage of free software in the country and considered to be an important initiative by military analysts when cyber is fast emerging as warfare domain.
Army sources said protection of vital information in cyber domain is critical for the forces deployed in the command which faces both China and Pakistan as even if the itinerary of a small convoy gets leaked, it can be proven dangerous.
At present, the Indian military is using foreign-origin software, which have been frequently coming under the scanner for working for their countries’ intelligence agencies and cannot be considered safe in the prevailing atmosphere of leaks and cyber espionage.
Currently, a number of equipment in the cyber infrastructure used by the public sector agencies supporting military communication is sourced from foreign manufacturers. Fearing espionage through foreign equipment, an advisory was issued couple of years ago by the Air Force to its personnel against using the phones of a particular phone firm. Army officials from the Corps of Signals – which is responsible for maintenance and looking after entire gamut of military communication – said creating our own information and communication technology infrastructure would also help in providing opportunity for ‘Make in India’ products in the sector.
India’s Cyber Security strategy
Ministry of Communications and Information Technology (India) define objectives as follows:
- To create a secure cyber ecosystem in the country, generate adequate trust and confidence in IT system and transactions in cyberspace and thereby enhance adoption of IT in all sectors of the economy.
- To create an assurance framework for design of security policies and promotion and enabling actions for compliance to global security standards and best practices by way of conformity assessment (Product, process, technology & people).
- To strengthen the Regulatory Framework for ensuring a SECURE CYBERSPACE ECOSYSTEM.
- To enhance and create National and Sectoral level 24X7 mechanism for obtaining strategic information regarding threats to ICT infrastructure, creating scenarios for response, resolution and crisis management through effective predictive, preventive, protective response and recovery actions.
- To improve visibility of integrity of ICT products and services by establishing infrastructure for testing & validation of security of such product.
- To create workforce for 500,000 professionals skilled in next 5 years through capacity building skill development and training.
- To provide fiscal benefit to businesses for adoption of standard security practices and processes.
- To enable Protection of information while in process, handling, storage & transit so as to safeguard privacy of citizen’s data and reducing economic losses due to cyber crime or data theft.
- To enable effective prevention, investigation and prosecution of cybercrime and enhancement of law enforcement capabilities through appropriate legislative intervention.
- Creating a secured Ecosystem.
- Creating an assurance framework.
- Encouraging Open Standards.
- Strengthening The regulatory Framework.
- Creating mechanism for Security Threats Early Warning, Vulnerability management and response to security threat.
- Securing E-Governance services.
- Protection and resilience of Critical Information Infrastructure.
- Promotion of Research and Development in cyber security.
- Reducing supply chain risks
- Human Resource Development (fostering education and training programs both in formal and informal sectors to support Nation’s cyber security needs and build capacity.
- Creating cyber security awareness.
- Developing effective Public Private Partnership.
- To develop bilateral and multilateral relationship in the area of cyber security with other country. (Information sharing and cooperation)
- Prioritized approach for implementation.
- Operationalisation of Policy
“Cybersecurity is an ecosystem where laws, organisations, skills, cooperation and technical implementation need to be in harmony to be most effective,” stated the ITU report. India’s highly skilled IT workforce should be trained and harnessed by the government for strategic use. There is requirement to develop comprehensive cyber defence strategy to not only defend India, create a social media counter strategy but also attack adversary networks.